IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access 2024: PIA Is More Reliable and Cost-Effective

Discover the key differences between IPVanish and Private Internet Access, and find out which VPN offers the perfect blend of security, performance, and affordability for your needs.
We receive compensation from the products and services mentioned in this story, but the opinions are the author's own. Compensation may impact where offers appear. We have not included all available products or offers. Learn more about how we make money and our editorial policies.

Best for Users Seeking High-Speed Performance

4.4
Editorial Rating
Learn More
On IPVanish's website

VPN
IPVanish
  • Provided consistently better upload speeds than PIA
  • Offers WireGuard, IKEv2, OpenVPN, and IPsec protocols
  • More expensive compared to PIA

Best for Budget Shoppers

5.0
Editorial Rating
Learn More
On Private Internet Access's website

VPN
Private Internet Access
  • Comes with unique features, like data breach monitoring
  • Offers the most affordable pricing plan at $2 a month for three years
  • Has not undergone a third-party audit for its no-logs policy

It's more important than ever to safeguard your online privacy and security. As there are numerous virtual private network (VPN) services available, it can be daunting to choose the right one. While IPVanish is an ideal choice if you are looking for strong encryption and user-friendly applications, Private Internet Access is suited for those seeking a budget-friendly VPN that also offers a strong commitment to privacy.

In this article, we will compare the costs, features, performance, and more between IPVanish and Private Internet Access (PIA), two popular VPN providers, so that you can make an informed decision about which to purchase.

In this article
IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access at a glance
IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: prices
IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: features
IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: internet speeds
IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: compatibility and ease of use
IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: customer service
PIA vs. IPVanish FAQs
IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: which is better?

IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access at a glance

Both IPVanish and Private Internet Access offer specific benefits that can cater to different user needs. The former is best suited for those seeking a VPN that offers high-speed performance, robust customer support, and good streaming. In contrast, PIA has an extensive server network and it is suitable for users on a budget, providing an affordable service without compromising any security features.

  • IPVanish: Best for users seeking high-speed performance
  • Private Internet Access: Best for budget shoppers

How do IPVanish and Private Internet Access compare?

IPVanish Private Internet Access
Our Pick
Starting price From $2.99/mo From $7.50/mo
Max # of connected devices Unlimited Unlimited
24/7 customer support
Compatibility Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS, gaming consoles, smart TVs, and routers Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS, gaming consoles, smart TVs, and routers
# of servers 2,000+ in 75+ countries 84 countries
VPN protocol WireGuard, IKEv2, OpenVPN, IPsec WireGuard, OpenVPN, IPsec
No-logs policy No logs No logs
Unblocks Netflix?
View IPVanish Plans View PIA Plans

Prices as of 04/24/2023.

In terms of pricing, Private Internet Access is definitely the more affordable option, with plans starting at under $2 per month with the three-year plan, in comparison, IPVanish's lowest plan starts at just over $3 per month with the two-year plan. Both IPVanish and PIA allow for as many connections as you want from one account or subscription.

Both VPNs support various VPN protocols. IPVanish offers WireGuard, IKEv2, OpenVPN, and IPsec. PIA offers WireGuard and OpenVPN, two of the most popular open-source VPN protocols available, as well as IPsec, but no IKEv2.

IPVanish and Private Internet Access both have a strict no-logs policy, which helps to ensure your online activities remain private. Additionally, both IPVanish and PIA can unblock Netflix, so you can access geo-restricted content.

IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: prices

IPVanish Private Internet Access
Our Pick
Price range $2.99–$12.99/mo $2.03–$11.99/mo
Best value plan 2-year plan for $2.99/mo 3-year + 3 months plan for $7.50/mo
Money-back guarantee Yes — 30-day risk-free Yes — 30-day risk-free
See Full Pricing Details See Full Pricing Details

Reviewed by Ryan L. Clancy
“In terms of pricing, Private Internet Access is definitely the more affordable option, with plans starting at under $2 per month with the three-year plan, in comparison, IPVanish's lowest plan starts at just over $3 per month with the two-year plan.”

IPVanish offers a monthly, annual, and biannual plan. These range from just over $3 per month for the biannual plan to almost $12 per month for the monthly plan. Opting for the annual plan offers savings of up to 62% and opting for the biannual plan offers savings of 72% compared to paying month-to-month. There is also a 30-day money-back guarantee provided, allowing users to try IPVanish’s services risk-free.

Private Internet Access offers a monthly, yearly, and three-year plan. These range from about $2 per month for the three-year plan to about $10 per month for the monthly plan. Opting for the three-year plan will offer savings of up to 83% when compared with the monthly plan. PIA also allows you to select the most suitable plan for you while being covered by their 30-day money-back guarantee, allowing you to test their service without worrying.

Winner: Private Internet Access wins by offering the best price plan thanks to its three-year plan at an average of $2 per month, making it the most affordable at half the price of IPVanish’s best value plan. Both VPNs offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, providing customers with a risk-free trial period.

IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: features

IPVanish Private Internet Access
Our Pick
Number of servers 2,000+ servers in 75+ countries 84 countries
No-logs policy No logs No logs
VPN headquarters Dallas, Texas Denver, Colorado
Encryption AES 256-bit AES 256-bit
VPN protocol WireGuard, IKEv2, OpenVPN, IPsec WireGuard, OpenVPN, IPsec
Kill switch
Split tunneling
Netflix support
Torrenting support
Data breach monitoring
Smart DNS
Blocks ads and trackers
Read IPVanish Review Get PIA

Data as of 04/12/2023

IPVanish and Private Internet Access share several features, such as a no-logs policy, AES 256-bit encryption, a kill switch, split tunneling, Netflix, and torrenting support. Both VPNs are headquartered in the United States, which may raise some privacy concerns due to the country's data retention policies. Neither VPN has undergone a public third-party audit for its no-logs policy, either.

While both VPNs offer multiple VPN protocols, IPVanish supports WireGuard, IKEv2, OpenVPN, and IPsec, whereas PIA only utilizes WireGuard, OpenVPN, and IPsec (on iOS). Private Internet Access offers a built-in ad and tracker blocker called PIA MACE. IPVanish also offers an ad and tracker blocker called RedMorph as a plug-in. This feature enhances your online privacy and security by preventing unwanted ads and trackers from collecting your data. PIA also offers data breach monitoring, while IPVanish doesn’t. This feature allows you to check if your email addresses have been part of a data breach, which is a handy security feature.

IPVanish vs. PIA: streaming support

Platform IPVanish Private Internet Access
Our Pick
Netflix
Amazon Prime Video
Hulu
BBC iPlayer
Disney+
HBO Max

Both IPVanish and Private Internet Access can unblock popular streaming platforms such as Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, and Hulu. That way, you can access a greater range of content from various regions worldwide by bypassing geographic restrictions.

Users who want to watch U.S.-exclusive shows on Netflix while traveling or living outside the United States will find it possible with both of these VPNs. In addition to this, you can access content from streaming services from other regions, like the U.K.’s BBC iPlayer while not being there.

By providing reliable access to a variety of streaming platforms, both VPNs are able to enhance the streaming experiences for their users. They ensure that users can enjoy their favorite TV shows and movies, regardless of their location or which streaming service they want to use. In addition to bypassing geo-restrictions, these VPNs can also aid in maintaining privacy and security while streaming.

Our IPVanish let us connect to an Adelaide, Australia, server and watch Australian Netflix shows with no problem.

We confirmed that PIA unblocked the U.K. Netflix library, since the only two available seasons of "Derry Girls" showed up. (The third season was only released in the U.S. at this time.)

Winner: Private Internet Access takes the lead for offering the best set of features and most univeral streaming ability.

IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: internet speeds

The influence of a VPN on internet speeds is an important part of its performance, so we tested IPVanish and Private Internet Access’s internet speeds. To guarantee a thorough examination, the speed tests were carried out on a variety of devices, including Android smartphones, iPhones, Windows laptops, and macOS PCs.

We began the speed testing by measuring download, upload, and download latency (ping) without a VPN connection. Then, we used IPVanish and Private Internet Access to connect to VPN servers in the following locations:

  • U.S. (to evaluate if the VPN creates a delay even while connecting to a nearby server)
  • U.K. or Europe
  • Canada
  • Australia

For each server location, we recorded the download speed, upload speed, and download latency (ping). When accessible, the precise nation, city, and state for each exam were indicated. This method allows us to compare the impact of VPNs on internet speeds in different countries and under different circumstances.

IPVanish vs. PIA speed test results 

Server location IPVanish Private Internet Access
Our Pick
Speed % difference with US server
  • Download: 42%
  • Upload: 124%
  • Download: -6%
  • Upload: -4%
Speed % difference with UK server
  • Download: 11%
  • Upload: 8%
  • Download: -6%
  • Upload: -4%
Speed % difference with AU server
  • Download: 14%
  • Upload: 23%
  • Download: -23%
  • Upload: -5%
Read IPVanish Review Get PIA

Latency, often referred to as "ping," is defined as the period of time it takes for data to travel between your device and VPN server. The lower the latency, the better, as this indicates faster response times, which is crucial for real-time applications such as online gaming and video conferencing. Using a VPN will increase latency due to the extra distance data must travel to reach your VPN server.

In our speed test results, both IPVanish and Private Internet Access demonstrated varying download speed, upload speed, and latency results depending on the server location. IPVanish provided consistently better upload speeds while download speeds appeared to be better in the U.S. with Private Internet Access.

IPVanish vs. PIA latency comparison

Server location IPVanish Private Internet Access
Our Pick
Latency % difference with US server 172% -113%
Latency % difference with UK server 186% -166%
Latency % difference with AU server 188% -176%

Winner: While IPVanish displayed higher download and upload speeds in some locations, Private Internet Access wins for showing more consistent speeds overall. In terms of latency, PIA had slightly lower latency in most server locations, with the exception of Australia.

IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: compatibility and ease of use

IPVanish Private Internet Access
Our Pick
Windows
macOS
Android
iOS
Linux
Router
Smart devices
Browser extensions Yes — Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Opera

As far as compatibility, both IPVanish and Private Internet Access provide support for the same operating systems, mobile apps, and even routers and smart devices. However, PIA has the edge with its browser extension compatibility, which IPVanish does not offer.

When it comes to user interfaces, both IPVanish and Private Internet Access offer intuitive and user-friendly designs. Each VPN has taken care to ensure that its applications are easy to navigate, making it simple for users to connect to servers, adjust settings, and access other features.

That being said, some users might find minor differences in layout and design preferences between the two VPNs. IPVanish features a visually appealing interface with a map view and easy-to-find settings, while PIA opts for a more minimalistic design with a focus on functionality. Overall, both VPNs provide a seamless experience, and users should have little trouble finding the settings they need or understanding how to use the applications.

Winner: Private Internet Access has the edge with its browser extension support. But IPVanish and PIA both offer extensive device compatibility and user-friendly interfaces, making them suitable for a wide range of users regardless of technical expertise.

IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: customer service

IPVanish Private Internet Access
24/7 live chat
Phone
Email
Support forums
Online guides

Both IPVanish and Private Internet Access offer comprehensive customer support options to assist their users. With 24/7 live chat, you can expect prompt assistance in resolving any issues you might encounter.

In addition, to live chat, both VPN providers offer email support and a wealth of resources, such as support forums and knowledge bases, to help users troubleshoot problems or learn more about their VPN's features. IPVanish also offers phone support, while PIA does not.

In general, users have reported positive experiences when interacting with the customer support teams of both IPVanish and Private Internet Access. The representatives are knowledgeable and responsive, ensuring that users receive the help they need in a timely manner.

IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: payment options

Both IPVanish and Private Internet Access offer a variety of payment options for users to choose from, including traditional credit card payments, PayPal, and various cryptocurrencies. For users seeking additional privacy and anonymity, using cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin can provide an extra layer of security, as these transactions do not require the disclosure of personal information.

IPVanish payment options

  • Credit cards
  • PayPal
  • Google Pay
  • Amazon Pay

PIA payment options

  • Credit cards
  • PayPal
  • Cryptocurrency (bitcoin, ether, litecoin, etc.)
  • Amazon Pay
  • Paygarden (supported U.S. gift cards)

Winner: We’re calling this one a tie. Private Internet Access offers support tools like a help center, 24/7 live chat, and email support. However, IPVanish also provides phone support. PIA does have more payment options, including several cryptocurrencies and gift cards, making it a better choice for those seeking versatility and anonymity in payment methods.

PIA vs. IPVanish FAQs


+

Is PIA VPN trustworthy?

Yes. PIA does not store any information from your online activities. In addition to this, they use strong encryption and secure VPN protocols to ensure your data stays protected.


+

Can IPVanish be tracked?

IPVanish uses advanced security features and a strict no-logs policy to ensure your online activities are kept private. While no VPN can guarantee complete anonymity, IPVanish's encryption and security measures make it extremely difficult for third parties to track your online activities. By hiding your IP address and encrypting your data, IPVanish helps protect your privacy and security on the internet.


+

How do I cancel a Private Internet Access subscription?

To cancel a Private Internet Access subscription, follow these steps:

  1. Log in to your PIA account on their website.
  2. Navigate to the "My Account" page.
  3. Click the "Turn off Auto-renewal" button.
  4. Follow the on-screen instructions to complete the cancellation process.

For more detailed information and assistance, you can visit PIA's support page.


+

What VPN is more affordable than IPVanish?

Private Internet Access (PIA) is a more affordable VPN option compared to IPVanish. PIA offers a three-year plan at about $2 per month, while IPVanish's lowest plan starts at around $3 per month. There are other VPN providers in the market with competitive pricing, but it's essential to consider the features, security, and reliability each VPN offers before making a decision based solely on price.

IPVanish vs. Private Internet Access: which is better?

IPVanish offers excellent security features, unlimited simultaneous connections, and a user-friendly interface, making it a great choice for users who want an easy-to-use VPN with good performance. However, its pricing is higher compared to Private Internet Access, which offers a more affordable option for users looking for a budget-friendly VPN.

Private Internet Access, on the other hand, boasts an extensive server network, competitive pricing, and robust security features. While it also provides a user-friendly interface and supports popular streaming platforms, PIA stands out with its affordability and the sheer number of servers available to users.

Considering the features, security, price, and server network, Private Internet Access is the better overall choice for most users. With its extensive server network, more than competitive pricing, and suitable strong security features, PIA is an excellent option for those looking for a reliable and cost-effective VPN service.

Save 82% on a 2-year subscription + 2 months free
5.0
Editorial Rating
Learn More
On Private Internet Access's website
VPN
Private Internet Access
  • More affordable than most other VPNs, including ExpressVPN and NordVPN
  • Fast internet speeds and strict no-logs policy
  • Unblocks Netflix and other streaming services
  • Antivirus and dedicated IP address cost extra
Author Details
Ryan Clancy is a freelance writer and blogger. With 5+ years of mechanical engineering experience, he's passionate about all things engineering and tech. He loves bringing engineering (especially mechanical) down to a level that everyone can understand.