All About Cookies is an independent, advertising-supported website. Some of the offers that appear on this site are from third-party advertisers from which All About Cookies receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear).
All About Cookies does not include all financial or credit offers that might be available to consumers nor do we include all companies or all available products. Information is accurate as of the publishing date and has not been provided or endorsed by the advertiser.
The All About Cookies editorial team strives to provide accurate, in-depth information and reviews to help you, our reader, make online privacy decisions with confidence. Here's what you can expect from us:
- All About Cookies makes money when you click the links on our site to some of the products and offers that we mention. These partnerships do not influence our opinions or recommendations. Read more about how we make money.
- Partners are not able to review or request changes to our content except for compliance reasons.
- We aim to make sure everything on our site is up-to-date and accurate as of the publishing date, but we cannot guarantee we haven't missed something. It's your responsibility to double-check all information before making any decision. If you spot something that looks wrong, please let us know.
Best for identity theft insurance
- Top-rated identity theft protection service
- Provides up to $3 million in coverage
- Multiple monitoring features including dark web, home title, and social media monitoring
Best for mid-tier monitoring
- Easy-to-use identity theft protection service
- Includes extra features like a password manager
LifeLock and Identity Guard are two of the best identity theft solutions. LifeLock is a bit more expensive, but it offers a more sizable identity theft insurance plan. While not as good, Identity Guard is still a substantial identity theft monitoring solution that comes with monitoring and a lower amount of insurance at a lower price.
We reviewed LifeLock vs. Identity Guard based on pricing, features, data security, and support to help you decide which one is best for you.
Which identity theft protection is the better value?
Which identity theft protection has the better features?
Which identity theft protection is more secure?
Which identity theft protection has better compatibility and customer service?
FAQs
LifeLock vs. Identity Guard: which is better?
LifeLock vs. Identity Guard overview
LifeLock and Identity Guard have similar offerings, but you’ll want to sign up for the highest level to get the most value out of either subscription. From our experience, LifeLock’s Standard plan and Identity Guard’s Value plan, which are the most basic tiers, didn’t include enough protection.
However, the highest-tier plans for both companies offer extensive solutions to help protect your identity in several different ways. While the expense may seem high, ID theft protection is worth it to keep your personal information safe.
LifeLock stands out for the amount of identity theft insurance you get with the Ultimate Plus Plan, while Identity Guard provides the most extensive monitoring with the Ultra plan.
- LifeLock: Best for identity theft insurance
- Identity Guard: Best for mid-tier monitoring
LifeLock vs. Identity Guard review at a glance
Our Pick
|
||
Star rating | ||
Price | $7.50–$38.99/mo for first yr | $6.67–$31.99/mo |
Types of identity monitoring | Dark web, social media, SSN, and home title monitoring | Dark web, social media, SSN, and home title monitoring |
Credit monitoring | ||
Identity theft insurance | Up to $3 million | Up to $1 million |
Identity restoration services | ||
24/7 customer support | ||
Get Norton LifeLock | Get Identity Guard |
LifeLock is the more expensive of the two services, but the higher price comes with additional identity theft insurance. LifeLock offers up to $3 million in insurance, while Identity Guard offers up to $1 million.
LifeLock also offers a variety of plans, including individual, family, and family with children. This gives you greater flexibility based on the number of people you’d like on your account. Identity Guard offers only an individual or family plan. It doesn’t offer the third option for those without kids. However, Identity Guard's family plan covers unlimited kids, while LifeLock's covers up to five.
Neither option gives you access to your FICO score, but they do provide updates to your VantageScore. For the most comprehensive look at your credit, you should look at both your FICO and VantageScore.
LifeLock pros and cons
- Offers up to $3 million in identity theft insurance with the Ultimate Plus plan
- Easy-to-use dashboard and mobile app
- Provides identity, financial, credit, and more types of monitoring
- No FICO score
- More expensive than Identity Guard
IdentityGuard pros and cons
- Includes white glove fraud resolution
- Three-bureau credit monitoring
- Offers safe browsing tool
- No FICO score
- No dedicated remediation assistance
Which identity theft protection is the better value?
LifeLock's ultimate plan offers more features than Identity Guard. While it's more expensive, it does have more value.
Our Pick
|
||
Price range | $7.50–$38.99/mo for first yr | $6.67–$31.99/mo |
Best value plan | LifeLock Ultimate Plus starting at $19.99/mo (billed annually) for first year | Identity Guard Ultra starting at $23.99/mo |
Money-back guarantee | 60 days | 60 days |
Get Norton LifeLock | Get Identity Guard |
LifeLock plans
LifeLock’s membership plans are structured similarly to Identity Guard, with three different tiers as well as family plans. LifeLock has family plans for two adults as well as family plans for two adults plus five kids.
- LifeLock Standard: LifeLock’s Standard plan is bare bones, but it does include identity and Social Security Number (SSN) alerts as well as Equifax credit monitoring. The Standard plan also includes dark web monitoring, data breach notifications, and utility account creation monitoring.
- LifeLock Advantage: Beyond the Standard plan features, the Advantage plan also includes additional reimbursement for stolen funds and personal expenses, which adds up to. $1.2 million in coverage. Advantage also provides monthly credit scores, phone takeover monitoring, alerts on crimes in your name, and identity lock, which allows you to lock your TransUnion credit file.
- LifeLock Ultimate Plus: The Ultimate Plus plan includes the features from the previous two tiers and adds a lot of great additional features, including home title monitoring, sex offender registry reports, and social media monitoring. The Ultimate Plus plan also gives you up to $3 million in coverage for an identity theft incident. It also expands on credit features by providing annual three-bureau credit reports and three-bureau credit monitoring.
Each LifeLock plan includes at least $1.05 million in identity theft coverage for lawyer fees, stolen funds reimbursement, and personal expenses. It also offers a 30-day free trial for new users to try the service and a 60-day money-back guarantee on annual plans.
Identity Guard plans
IdentityGuard offers several individual and family plans to help meet your identity protection needs. All of the individual plans cover one individual, while the family plan gives you protection for five adults and unlimited children.
- Identity Guard Value: Identity Guard’s Value plan leaves a lot of gaps if you’re looking for comprehensive identity protection. You do get $1 million in identity theft insurance and monitoring for data breaches, high-risk transactions, and dark web monitoring. Unfortunately, you don’t get access to your credit scores or any credit bureau monitoring. All tiers come with safe browsing tools and a password manager.
- Identity Guard Total: The Total plan offers a bit more coverage, but it's still lacking some important features. You’ll get credit monitoring and a monthly credit score, but you won't be able to lock your credit — which can be an important tool after an identity theft incident. The Total plan adds bank account monitoring along with the features from the Value plan.
- Identity Guard Ultra: The Ultra plan includes all the bells and whistles. With the Ultra plan, you get fraud resolution services to help you after an incident. It also adds monitoring for social media, credit cards, home titles, among others. You can also use Experian Credit Lock and access your annual credit reports from Experian, Equifax, and TransUnion.
Identity Guard offers a 60-day money-back guarantee on all annual plans.
Which identity theft protection has the better features?
Identity Guard and Norton LifeLock offer similar features, such as credit, social media, and SSN monitoring.
Feature | ||
SSN monitoring | ||
Financial activity alerts | ||
Credit monitoring | ||
3-bureau credit reports | Yes — Experian, Equifax, TransUnion | Yes — Experian, Equifax, TransUnion |
Credit score | ||
Credit lock and freeze | ||
Identity theft insurance | Up to $3 million | Up to $1 million |
Dark web monitoring | ||
Social media monitoring | ||
Home title monitoring | ||
USPS address change alerts | ||
Get Norton LifeLock | Get Identity Guard |
LifeLock and Identity Guard’s top-tier plans provide an abundance of monitoring to help keep you safe online and offline. With both services, you get real-time monitoring in the following areas:
- Dark web: Scans the dark web for instances of your email addresses, passwords, phone numbers, or other personal information. If you know that your information is on the dark web, you can change passwords or information to mitigate potential theft.
- Bank accounts: Monitors your financial accounts for suspicious activity, such as large withdrawals. These alerts enable you to stop the fraudsters quickly if they have access to your accounts.
- Social media: Monitors your social media profiles and alerts you of abnormal activity or suspicious links. Identity thieves can use social media to gain personally identifiable information about you or to find new victims based on your friend list.
- Home title: Notifies you in case of any changes to your home title or deed. Keeps fraudsters from gaining access to your home equity or jeopardizing ownership of your home.
- Sex offender: Scans the sex offender registry for your name and personal information and alerts you if your name or information is found on the registry.
- USPS address changes: Alerts you to any changes made to your address through the United States Postal Service.
You won’t find too many differences between LifeLock and Identity Guard as far as monitoring. Neither LifeLock nor IdentityGuard offers access to your FICO score. While the VantageScore is becoming more popular, the FICO score is still the most widely used for new credit. Without access to your FICO score, you may not have an accurate picture of your credit.
LifeLock does offer more substantial identity theft insurance coverage. With the Premium Ultra plan, you can get up to $3 million in protection to help offset identity theft losses. The Standard plan starts by offering $1.05 million, which is slightly more than Identity Guard's standard $1 million.
Which identity theft protection is more secure?
Protecting your personally identifiable information is a critical component of keeping your identity secure. When looking for identity protection, it is important to ensure they’re protecting your data during the process. We looked at the privacy policies of both solutions to make sure they were collecting only necessary data and that they weren’t sharing data unless it was necessary as part of the solution.
LifeLock vs. Identity Guard data security
Both LifeLock and Identity Guard keep your identity secure. However, to do that they collect and save your personal data.
Collects data | ||
Shares data with third parties | Minimal | Minimal |
Get Norton LifeLock | Get Identity Guard |
Both LifeLock and Identity Guard offer two-factor and multi-factor authentication to help protect your account information. Multi-factor authentication can keep your account safe even if someone has access to your password. In order to gain access to your account, the fraudster will also need access to your other authentication items, such as a phone, biometrics, or email.
Identity Guard’s parent company is Aura, which is another identity theft product on the market. If you look at Identity Guard’s privacy policy, you’ll be redirected to the Aura policy.
Both Identity Guard and LifeLock need a significant amount of personal information in order to perform the services outlined, so you’ll have to give up some data to gain the benefits of the service. We didn’t see any red flags in either privacy policy, just be aware of the data they share.
Which identity theft protection has better compatibility and customer service?
LifeLock and Identity Guard are compatible with Android and iOS, and offer remediation services and lost wallet support. However, LifeLock goes the extra step by offering 24/7 live chat support.
Platform | Our Pick
|
|
Android | ||
iOS | ||
Dedicated restoration specialists | ||
Lost wallet remediation | ||
24/7 customer supportt | ||
Customer support options | Live chat, phone, email, forums, online guides | Phone, email, online guides |
Get Norton LifeLock | Get Identity Guard |
Neither LifeLock nor Identity Guard has desktop apps for Windows or macOS. However, you can access your identity theft protection accounts from any web browser. From our testing, we thought LifeLock’s browser dashboard was more intuitive and easier to use than Identity Guard.
Additionally, you can access either identity theft protection service from their iOS or Android mobile app. The LifeLock mobile app was also more user-friendly than Identity Guard. We’ve used Identity Guard for some time, and each time we got an alert via email, it was a bit of a hassle to find the actual information — especially on a mobile device. You can’t access the full details of an alert from the app, so you’ll have to log in to the website to get all the pertinent information.
Both LifeLock and Identity Guard offer content libraries with helpful tips on what to do if you encounter identity theft or other issues with your identity. LifeLock also offers community forums, where you can ask other LifeLock users questions.
LifeLock comes with 24/7 member support via live chat, whereas Identity Guard offers 24/7 support via phone. This is a notable feature since identity theft can happen at any time. Being able to access customer support, even in the middle of the night, can help you mitigate any damages from identity theft.
Identity Guard also offers customer support via email, but only during specific business hours and with no support on Sundays.
FAQs
What is the downside to LifeLock?
The downside to LifeLock is that you’ll need to sign up for its Ultimate Plus plan to get the most out of the service, which can be expensive.
Is there a worthwhile Identity Guard alternative?
Yes, there are several other worthwhile identity theft protection services. LifeLock is one alternative to Identity Guard that we liked. There are also several LifeLock alternatives to consider.
Has LifeLock ever been hacked?
In January 2023, LifeLock confirmed that a hack happened that compromised the accounts of customers’ password managers. LifeLock notified customers of the attack and informed them that their personal information may have been accessed by a third party. However, LifeLock said that the attack was based on previously exposed credentials used to log in to the site and not a compromise of its systems.
Is Identity Guard legitimate?
Yes, Identity Guard and its parent company, Aura, are reputable companies. Aura has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.
LifeLock vs. Identity Guard: which is better?
While LifeLock and Identity Guard seem similar, we determined that LifeLock is ahead of Identity Guard in the race for the best identity theft protection service.
LifeLock is only a few dollars more than the comparable Identity Guard plan. We found the extra expense worth it, especially for the additional insurance coverage in the unfortunate event that we are a victim of identity theft. It’s also easier to use and navigate than Identity Guard.
Signing up for an identity theft protection program can both help you prevent identity theft and help mitigate any issues if your identity is stolen. However, identity theft programs are effective only if you use them, so make sure you set up your account in its entirety and pay attention to the monitoring alerts you receive. An unread monitoring alert is sort of like the old question, “If a tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does it make a sound?”
Category | Our Pick
|
|
Value | ||
Features | Tie | Tie |
Test results | Tie | Tie |
User experience | ||
24/7 customer supportt | ||
Customer support options | Live chat, phone, email, forums, online guides | Phone, email, online guides |
Get Norton LifeLock | Get Identity Guard |
Top identity theft protection alternatives
Although we've laid out the best use cases for LifeLock and Identity Guard, these services still might not be the best option for you. Here are some additional identity theft protection services to consider:
Service | |||
Individual monthly price | Starts at $9.00/mo (billed annually) | Starts at $10.00/mo | Starts at $14.95/mo |
Family monthly price | Starts at $25.00/mo (billed annually) | N/A | Starts at $25.00/mo (billed annually) |
ID theft insurance | Up to $1 million | Up to $2 million | Up to $3 million |
Credit monitoring | |||
3-bureau credit reports | |||
Details | Get Aura Read Aura Review |
Get Omniwatch Read Omniwatch Review |
Get IDShield Read IDShield Review |