All About Cookies is an independent, advertising-supported website. Some of the offers that appear on this site are from third-party advertisers from which All About Cookies receives compensation. This compensation may impact how and where products appear on this site (including, for example, the order in which they appear).
All About Cookies does not include all financial or credit offers that might be available to consumers nor do we include all companies or all available products. Information is accurate as of the publishing date and has not been provided or endorsed by the advertiser.
The All About Cookies editorial team strives to provide accurate, in-depth information and reviews to help you, our reader, make online privacy decisions with confidence. Here's what you can expect from us:
- All About Cookies makes money when you click the links on our site to some of the products and offers that we mention. These partnerships do not influence our opinions or recommendations. Read more about how we make money.
- Partners are not able to review or request changes to our content except for compliance reasons.
- We aim to make sure everything on our site is up-to-date and accurate as of the publishing date, but we cannot guarantee we haven't missed something. It's your responsibility to double-check all information before making any decision. If you spot something that looks wrong, please let us know.
If a smart speaker or smart display is on your gift list this year, spend a few minutes reviewing the privacy label before you wrap it.
A new study found these devices link more personal information directly to their users than any other popular gadget category sold on Black Friday, including smartwatches, robot vacuums, and baby monitors.[1]
The research reportedly comes from IT Asset Management Group, which pulled 359 gadgets and 95 companion apps from 749 listings across 15 Amazon Best Sellers lists captured in November.
Researchers then read the privacy disclosures that app makers are required to post: Apple's App Store privacy labels for 95 apps and Google Play's Data Safety pages for 90.
“For consumers, the privacy labels are a clear way to see what types of data apps will be collecting about you,” Richy George, ITAMG’s chief revenue officer, said in the report.
The kids' gift list raises its own flags
The regifting gap nobody mentions
What to check before you buy or regift
Smart speakers link the most data
Apps tied to smart speakers and smart displays linked an average of 10 of the 35 personal data types tracked on Apple's privacy labels directly to the user, according to the study.
That included names, email addresses, precise location, and health data.
Smartwatches, fitness trackers and smart rings came in lowest, by comparison, linking an average of just 4 data types across the 25 apps the study reviewed. But even that category had a catch: six of the 16 apps in the entire study that admitted to tracking people across other companies' apps and websites were smartwatch apps, more than any other category.
If you're shopping for a smart speaker or a wearable this year, the device that seems the least invasive on paper isn't necessarily the one that shares the least with outside companies.
Robot vacuum apps disclosed collecting more categories of information than they linked to users. Apple allows developers to classify information as unlinked when they apply protections that prevent it from being connected to someone’s identity.
On Google Play, 43 of 90 apps disclosed sharing some data with other companies, 7 said collected data can't be deleted, and 8 said it isn't encrypted while in transit.
The kids' gift list raises its own flags
The study separated out 11 apps tied to gadgets marketed as children's gifts, and the numbers there are worth a second look before anything goes under the tree. Six of those apps collect contact details, four collect audio, and three collect photos or videos, according to the privacy labels researchers reviewed.
These disclosures don’t establish whether the information belongs to a child or the adult managing the account. Before setting up a connected toy, check the app’s privacy policy for how it handles children’s information and whether recording features are optional.
The regifting gap nobody mentions
Beyond what the apps collect, the study dug into something retailers rarely put front and center: what happens to all that data when a device changes hands. Researchers checked 155 device brands' own support pages for three things: instructions on removing a device from an account, instructions on factory resetting it, and any guidance telling owners to do both before selling or giving the gadget away.
The results were lopsided. Nearly half of the brands checked, 75 of 155, explained none of the three steps on their support pages. Only 18 brands, about 12%, walked owners through all three.
George added that nearly half the brands his team checked don't explain how to remove an account from a device before it changes hands.
What to check before you buy or regift
Before buying a connected gadget, find its companion app in the app store:
- On Apple’s App Store, check the App Privacy section for information linked to you or used to track you.
- On Google Play, open Data safety and select “See details” to review collection, sharing and security disclosures.
Check what the app needs to function and what you can decline. If the listing leaves you unsure, read the developer’s privacy policy before creating an account.
If a listing is vague on any of those points, that's a reasonable reason to keep looking or dig into the brand's privacy policy before setting up the device.
If you're giving away, selling, or regifting a device you've already used, don't assume a factory reset erases everything tied to your account. Remove the device from your account first, then reset it, and check the brand's support pages for the exact steps, since so many skip that guidance entirely.
For voice assistants in particular, it's worth reviewing what the microphone has been listening to and clearing stored recordings before the device leaves your house.