Total Adblock vs. Adblock Plus 2024: A Landslide Victory

Between Total Adblock and Adblock Plus, Total Adblock takes the victory for superior ad and tracker blocking, enhanced antivirus software protection, and perfect test scores.
We receive compensation from the products and services mentioned in this story, but the opinions are the author's own. Compensation may impact where offers appear. We have not included all available products or offers. Learn more about how we make money and our editorial policies.

Best for pop-ups and tracker blocking

4.9
Editorial Rating
Learn More
On Total Adblock's website

Ad Blocker
Total Adblock
BLACK FRIDAY: Up to 80% off
  • Instantly blocks distracting ads on millions of websites, including Facebook and YouTube ads
  • Blocks third-party trackers to protect your privacy and information
  • Improves page load times and enables faster browsing

Best for blocking YouTube ads

4.4
Editorial Rating
Learn More
On Adblock Plus's website

Ad Blocker
Adblock Plus
  • Free product blocks ads, pop-up, trackers, push notifications, social media icons tracking, and even YouTube video ads
  • Open-source software allows for custom filtering and community-based support

Total Adblock and Adblock Plus are two ad-blocking services that scan websites as they load, identify potential ads, and remove these annoyances from your screen. Both services do that well, blocking ads on YouTube, Forbes, and other popular websites.

We’ve determined that Total Adblock is a better service for its lower monthly rate, having passed all of our block tests with near-perfect scores, and even offering antivirus protection. If you’re looking for a more pared down ad blocker, Adblock Plus works great against YouTube ads.

In this article
Total Adblock vs. Adblock Plus
Prices
Features
Test results
Compatibility and customer support
FAQs
Total Adblock vs. Adblock Plus: Which is better?

Total Adblock vs. Adblock Plus

Ad blockers can help minimize your risk of interacting with cyberthreats by blocking online advertisements, banners, pop-up notifications, and more. The best ad blockers block trackers that monitor your online activity just as well.

For the best overall ad and tracker blocking, we recommend Total Adblock. However, we were impressed by Adblock Plus’s ability to block YouTube ads. It blocked ads at the beginning and prevented ads from loading in the middle of a video.

Best for Best for pop-ups and tracker blocking Best for blocking YouTube ads
Price From $1.59/mo (billed annually) From $3.33/mo (billed annually)
Ads blocked on Forbes 12 56
Does it block YouTube ads?
CompatibilityChrome, Edge, Opera, Safari Chrome, Firefox, Safari, Opera, Edge, Yandex
Mobile compatibility Android, iOS Android, iOS
Learn more Get Total Adblock

Read Total Adblock Review

Get Adblock Plus

Read Adblock Plus Review

Total Adblock pros and cons

Pros
  • Hands-off ad-blocking experience
  • Premium plan offers Total AV antivirus protection
  • Blocks third-party trackers to protect privacy and information
Cons
  • Free version excludes top 15,000 websites
  • Annoying pop-ups prompt you to upgrade to premium version

Adblock Plus pros and cons

Pros
  • Free option works well blocking ads
  • Comes with Allowlist to approve select ads
  • Blocks YouTube ads
Cons
  • Premium subscription is required to block pop-up videos, survey requests, and notifications
  • Inadequate at blocking trackers per our testing

Total Adblock vs. Adblock Plus: prices

Our Pick
Price range Free or $1.59/mo Free to $4.00/mo
Best value plan Total Adblock Pro for $1.59/mo (billed annually) Adblock Plus Premium Yearly for $3.33/mo (billed annually)
Free version available
Money-back guarantee Yes — 30 days Yes — 60 days
Learn more Get Total Adblock

Read Total Adblock Review

Get Adblock Plus

Read Adblock Plus Review

Both services offer free plans, but those leave something to be desired. Total Adblock’s free plan excludes the top 15,000 websites from ad blocking while Adblock Plus’s free plan doesn’t block specific ad types like pop-ups and video ads.

As such, we think investing in the premium plan is well worth the price. Total Adblock Pro costs $1.59/mo (billed annually) for the first year, and it can block unlimited ads. It also comes with TotalAV antivirus protection.

Adblock Plus Premium costs $1.59/mo (billed annually), which is about double the price of Total Adblock. Its additional features include the ability to block floating videos, site notifications, and cookie consent pop-ups.

Total Adblock and Adblock Plus both offer money-back guarantees to give you time to determine if the service is a good fit for you. Total Adblock’s money-back guarantee is good for 30 days, while Adblock Plus offers a hefty 60-day guarantee.

Winner: You get more bang for your buck with Total Adblock. It offers ad and tracker blocking, antivirus protection, and more for a lower monthly price.

Total Adblock vs. Adblock Plus: features

Feature
Our Pick
Whitelisting
Blacklisting
Ads blocked counter
Bypasses paywalls
Block pop-up ads
Block tracking
Block video ads
Block banner ads
Block push ads
Learn more Get Total Adblock

Read Total Adblock Review

Get Adblock Plus

Read Adblock Plus Review

On paper, Total Adblock and Adblock Plus are nearly identical in features. They both offer whitelisting; block YouTube ads, pop-up ads, notifications, and banner ads; and protect your device from trackers that monitor your activity.

Adblock Plus anti-tracking features
Adblock Plus anti-tracking features

However, we found Adblock Plus to be lacking in performance. Our testing proved that it actually failed at blocking trackers.

Trackers are installed to keep tabs on you and your online habits, usually for advertising or analytical purposes. While Adblock Plus performed the function it’s designed to do — block ads — we were disappointed in the functionality of the tracker blocker.

But, we were impressed with Adblock’s ability to block ads on YouTube. It blocked pre-roll ads and eliminated any ads that could interrupt our video stream.

Total Adblock offers an additional layer of security in offering antivirus protection called TotalAV. TotalAV offers real-time antivirus protection, encrypted web browsing, and data breach monitoring. Extra security features are always a win in our opinion.

The TotalAV Adblocker comes with several features including a Web Shield, Ad Block Pro, Clear Cookies, and Clear History.
TotalAV toggle features icons

Winner: Not only is Total Adblock less expensive, but its functionality, paired with the additional security provided by antivirus protection, makes it the clear winner here.

Total Adblock vs. Adblock Plus: test results

We test the ad blockers we review with AdBlock Tester, the Electronic Frontier Foundation’s (EFF’s) Cover Your Tracks, and Can You Block It tools.

AdBlock Tester looks at contextual advertising, banner ads, analytics tools, and more. Cover Your Tracks tests ad blockers for effectiveness against trackers, and Can You Block It checks ad blockers against banner ads, interstitial ads, and ad blocker detection warnings.

Our Pick
Adblock Tester score 100/100 100/100
Cover Your Tracks score 2/3 0/3
Can You Block It score 3/3 3/3
YouTube ads blocked
Paywalls blocked
Learn more Get Total Adblock

Read Total Adblock Review

Get Adblock Plus

Read Adblock Plus Review

Total Adblock got top marks with both ad blocker tests. It also successfully blocked tracking ads and invisible trackers, having only failed the fingerprinting test.

With Adblock Tester, Adblock Plus initially scored 77/100, passing the tests for contextual and banner advertising while failing some tests for error monitoring and failing to load. After we enabled the Block additional tracking and Block social media icons tracking features, we received a 100/100 score.

However, the Cover Your Tracks test results indicated that Adblock Plus can’t protect our browser from any form of tracking. This could be a deterrent for anyone wanting to browse online anonymously.

Winner: It’s hard to say if Adblock Plus’s less-than-desirable test scores were due to browser settings or just an ineffective feature. Regardless, Total Adblock’s near-perfect score in ad and tracker blocker is unbeatable.

Total Adblock vs. Adblock Plus: compatibility and customer support

Our Pick
Windows
macOS
Android
iOS
Linux
Browser extensions Chrome, Edge, Opera, Safari  Chrome, Firefox, Safari, Opera, Edge, Yandex
24/7 customer support
Customer support options Live chat, email, phone, online guides Forums, online guides, submit a ticket
Learn more Get Total Adblock

Read Total Adblock Review

Get Adblock Plus

Read Adblock Plus Review

Total Adblock was easy to install and use. We quickly installed the extension on Chrome by following the prompts. It’s a great option for a “set it and forget it” ads-free experience. Once installed, you can click on the extension at any time to see what ads the software is blocking.

Overall, our experience was pleasant. However, Total Adblock sends pop-up banners and notifications letting you know you’ve reached your ad limit or your trial has expired, which can become annoying.

Total Adblock Expired Pop-Up

Similarly, Adblock Plus was also user-friendly. We installed Adblock Plus on a Safari browser on macOS and iOS and tested the Chrome extension. Ads were blocked, and we had a clean, ad-free browsing experience.

We especially liked the Acceptable Ads feature. This allows you to add certain sites to your Allowlist to prevent ads from being blocked. That way, you can support your favorite creators who rely on ad revenue.

Adblock Plus comes with an Allowlist that lets you select trusted sites where you don't mind seeing ads.

However, customer support for Adblock Plus is lacking. It only offers an email address and online guides. We would love more support options here like a live chat or a phone number.

Total Adblock includes live chat and a phone number you can call, along with email and online guides. We were only able to find this information in Total Adblock’s terms of service, so we wish it was more forthcoming about our options.

Winner: Total Adblock wins for its more inclusive customer support.

FAQs


+

Is Total Adblock the same as Adblock?

Despite similar names and similar ad blocking features, Total Adblock and Adblock are different services with different pricing, features, and customer service options.


+

What are the disadvantages of Total Adblock?

The main disadvantage of Total Adblock is its free plan. While it is a good ad-blocking service, the free version excludes 15,000 of the most popular websites and incessantly issues pop-up notifications and banners saying your trial has expired.


+

Is there anything better than Adblock Plus?

There are many other ad blockers that offer additional features, coupled with ad blocking benefits. If you’re looking for bundled protection, it might be worth looking into one of our alternatives or our list of the best ad blockers.


+

Is Total Adblock the best ad blocker?

We consider Total Adblock to be one of the best ad blockers. It scored perfectly on our tests and provides a hands-off ad-blocking experience to enjoy anonymous browsing. If you opt for the premium plan, Total Adblock has added security measures like antivirus protection.

Total Adblock vs. Adblock Plus: Which is better?

Total Adblock is an above-average ad blocker. While the free plan leaves some to be desired, the premium plan is well worth the money. It provides ad blocking, tracker blocking, and real-time antivirus protection, so you can have an enjoyable browsing experience free of ads and trackers.

Adblock Plus is a good ad blocker, but our testing left us wondering if it was a system error or a browser error that yielded less-than-perfect ad-blocking test results.

Although both ad-blocking services offer good features and passed our ad-blocking tests, we think Total Adblock is the better option for the price and extra features.

4.9
Ad Blocker
Total Adblock
  • Instantly blocks distracting ads on millions of websites, including Facebook and YouTube ads
  • Blocks third-party trackers to protect your privacy and information
  • Improves page load times and enables faster browsing
Learn More

Total Adblock and Adblock Plus alternatives

In the duel between Total Adblock vs. Adblock Plus, our winner is Total Adblock. But, if neither of those is the right fit for you, there are other ad-blocking services you may want to look into.

Our guide to the best ad blockers can help you find the best ad blocker for you. Here are some other options to consider.


Threat Protection

CleanWeb
Best for Best overall Best for blocking streaming ads Best for blocking social media trackers
Price Starts at $1.59/mo (billed annually) Starts at $2.99/mo (billed every two years) Starts at $3.50/mo
Free version?
Adblock Tester score 91/100 98/100 97/100
Cover Your Tracks score 2/30.5/32/3
Can You Block It score 2/3 3/3 2/3
Blocks YouTube ads?
Compatibility Threat Protection:
Windows, macOS

Threat Protection Lite:
Windows, macOS, Android, iOS, Linux, Chrome, Edge, Firefox

Windows, macOS, Android, iOS, Linux, Chrome, Edge, Firefox, FireTV Windows, macOS, Android, iOS, Chrome, Firefox, Safari
Learn more Get NordVPN Threat Protection Get Surfshark CleanWeb Get AdLock

Best Basic Adblocker — Including YouTube Video Ads
4.9
Editorial Rating
Learn More
On Total Adblock's website
Ad Blocker
Total Adblock
BLACK FRIDAY: Up to 80% off
  • Instantly blocks distracting ads on millions of websites, including Facebook and YouTube ads
  • Blocks third-party trackers to protect your privacy and information
  • Improves page load times and enables faster browsing
Author Details
Courtney Daybell brings over 15 years of experience in print journalism and holds a B.A. in Communications from Brigham Young University. Her focus has shifted to cyber security, where she specializes in topics such as identity theft protection, password managers, antivirus software, and more.