HostGator vs. GoDaddy 2025: Flawless Victory, But For Which Host?

HostGator is the better choice for most users seeking shared web hosting, delivering stronger security features, more transparent support, and better long-term value without the constant upselling that plagues GoDaddy's service. While GoDaddy offers modern NVMe storage and automatic daily backups, these minor advantages evaporate once you factor in the hidden costs.

In this comprehensive HostGator vs GoDaddy comparison, we'll take a close look at the two hosts' shared hosting features, pricing, security, customer support, and performance results based on our in-house testing. This will help you make an informed decision on which host is right for you.

HostGator vs. GoDaddy review at a glance

• HostGator: Best overall choice for most use cases
• GoDaddy: Best for database-heavy websites that need NVMe storage

	Our Pick
Star rating	4.7 AllAboutCookies writers and editors score products based on a number of objective features as well as our expert editorial assessment. Our partners do not influence how we rate products.	4.8 AllAboutCookies writers and editors score products based on a number of objective features as well as our expert editorial assessment. Our partners do not influence how we rate products.
Starting price	$3.75/mo	$5.99/mo
Money-back guarantee	Yes — 30 days	Yes — 30 days
Uptime guarantee	99%	99.9%
Monthly visits	40K - 400K	Unmetered
Number of websites	10 - 100	1 - 25
Storage	10 GB - 100 GB SSD	25 GB - 75 GB NVMe
Free SSL certificate	On all plans	Starting at Deluxe*
Free domain for a year	On all plans	On all plans
Learn more	Get HostGator Read HostGator Review	Get GoDaddy Read GoDaddy Review

HostGator pros and cons

HostGator's greatest strength is its no-nonsense approach to value: Essential features come included rather than hidden behind paywalls. Every shared hosting plan includes malware scanning, firewall protection, staging environments, a free SSL certificate, and a free CDN.

You can also host 10-100 websites per account, depending on your plan tier, making it ideal for managing multiple projects or client sites without paying for separate hosting.

HostGator's downsides are that it uses older SSD storage instead of modern NVMe technology, and backups are run weekly rather than daily. In addition, renewal prices jump significantly after the introductory period. This is a common industry practice, but HostGator's price increases are steeper than those of some competitors.

GoDaddy pros and cons

GoDaddy excels in a few technical areas. For instance, it uses modern NVMe storage, which offers significantly faster read/write speeds than HostGator's SSD drives. The daily automatic backups provide more frequent protection than HostGator's weekly schedule, and GoDaddy's 99.9% uptime guarantee edges out HostGator's 99% commitment.

However, GoDaddy’s biggest drawback across the board (not just on its shared web hosting plans) is its pricing structure. Case in point is the Economy plan. It comes with a free SSL certificate only in the first year, and then starting in year two, GoDaddy charges ~$120 per year for it. If you do the math, that comes out to $10 per month. Add that $10 to the monthly cost of the Economy plan itself, and it becomes more expensive than the tier two Deluxe plan, which includes the SSL for free.

In effect, GoDaddy’s pricing model funnels you into the Deluxe plan.

Another example is that GoDaddy charges you for foundation-level security after only one month. Standard security features, such as a web application firewall (WAF) and malware scanning, are included on all HostGator plans but are considered a luxury with GoDaddy.

Which web hosting service has the best core features?

With very few exceptions, HostGator has the better core features across all web hosting plans.

	Our Pick
Number of contributors	User roles supported - no hard cap	User roles supported - no hard cap
Websites per account	10 - 100	1 - 25
Storage available	10 GB - 100 GB SSD	25 GB - 75 GB NVMe
Bandwidth	Unmetered	Unmetered
Monthly visits	40K - 400K	Unmetered
Staging environment	On all plans
Migration assistance	On all plans - free via transfer wizard + paid	On all plans
Email	5 - unlimited boxes per account	1 - unlimited boxes per account
Control panel	On all plans - HostGator customer portal + cPanel	On all plans - GoDaddy customer portal + cPanel
Website builder
Hosting types available	Shared / WordPress / ecommerce / semi-managed VPS / dedicated server / reseller / email-only	Shared / WordPress / VPS
Learn more	Get HostGator Read HostGator Review	Get GoDaddy Read GoDaddy Review

One of the few areas where GoDaddy excels over HostGator is in storage type. As mentioned, the former uses modern NVMe, while the latter relies on older generation SSD. However, this advantage matters most for database-heavy applications and high-traffic sites processing thousands of simultaneous requests.

For typical small business websites and blogs, the real-world speed difference between NVMe and SSD is minimal because page loading is usually bottlenecked by other factors like image optimization and network latency.

HostGator pulls ahead where it actually counts for the average user. The ability to host more websites per account is huge for anyone managing multiple projects or client sites. Just as importantly, HostGator includes staging environments on all plans — a critical feature that lets you test changes, updates, and new designs on a clone of your site before going live. GoDaddy's omission of staging is a glaring weakness, especially since even budget hosts commonly include it.

In terms of monthly traffic limits, HostGator provides suggested amounts, giving you a good set of parameters when choosing a plan. In contrast, GoDaddy doesn't have explicitly stated limits. That might sound appealing, but in practice, if your site gets enough traffic that it overwhelms GoDaddy's shared servers, you can expect an email or a phone call asking you to upgrade. HostGator's transparent approach lets you plan accordingly, while GoDaddy's unmetered limit leaves you guessing until you hit an invisible ceiling.

Which web host has the best performance and reliability?

HostGator gets another win in this category thanks to one key tie breaker: It includes a free CDN on all plans, while GoDaddy unsurprisingly charges for it after the first month.

Otherwise, the hosts’ actual performance metrics — First Contentful Paint or FCP (how fast the first element loads on a web page) and Largest Contentful Paint or LCP (how fast the largest element loads) — were nearly identical in our hands-on testing.

	Our Pick
Uptime guarantee	99%	99.9%
Tested uptime	100%	99.931%
Average performance score	100	100
Average FCP	0.4 seconds	0.4 seconds
Average LCP	0.56 seconds	0.5 seconds
Learn more	Get HostGator Read HostGator Review	Get GoDaddy Read GoDaddy Review

Both GoDaddy and HostGator delivered impressive and virtually indistinguishable performance scores. They tied with identical FCP times, and even though GoDaddy's LCP clocked in marginally faster, 0.06 seconds is not perceptible to actual visitors. For context, Google recommends that LCP be under 2.5 seconds for a good user experience [1], and both hosts crushed this benchmark by over 400%.

The uptime numbers tell a similar story. GoDaddy promises 99.9% and HostGator 99%. In our actual testing, the two were flipped. HostGator achieved 100% while GoDaddy came in at 99.931%. However, the real-life effect of this gap is only a few minutes. Unless you're running a high-traffic ecommerce site where every second costs revenue, then 0.00069% downtime won’t kill your site.

The real differentiator is the CDN. HostGator includes one on all of its plans at no extra cost. This caches your site across multiple global locations to improve loading speeds for visitors, regardless of where they're logging in from. GoDaddy includes a CDN only during your first month, and then charges for it. With performance metrics this close, the CDN gives HostGator a meaningful advantage.

Which web host is the better value?

HostGator is generally cheaper and bundles in more features on all its shared hosting plans, making it the better overall value option.

	Our Pick
Price range	$3.75-$13.95/mo	$5.99-$12.99/mo
Best value plan	Baby for $4.50/mo	Deluxe for $7.99/mo
Money-back guarantee	Yes — 30 days	Yes — 30 days
Free domain for a year	On all plans	On all plans
Free CDN	On all plans	No*
Free SSL	On all plans	Starting at Deluxe**
Learn more	Get HostGator Read HostGator Review	Get GoDaddy Read GoDaddy Review

HostGator plans

HostGator’s web hosting comes with a double guarantee: a 30-day money-back guarantee and 99% uptime. All plans also include: a free domain in the first year, a site migration wizard, staging sites, a free CDN, cPanel (with email), and managed WordPress updates. Security is backed by free SSL certificates, free malware scanning, a web application firewall, DDoS protection, and weekly website backups. Support is 24/7 via chat, with phone support added from the Baby plan and up.

• Hatchling plan: 10 websites, 10 GB SSD storage, and up to 40,000 visits per month
• Baby plan: 20 websites, 20 GB SSD storage, and up to 50,000 visits per month
• Business plan: 50 websites, 50 GB SSD storage, up to 200,000 visits per month, malware detection + removal, and free domain privacy for the first year
• Pro plan: 100 websites, 100 GB SSD storage, up to 400,000 visits per month, malware detection + removal, and free domain privacy for the first year

GoDaddy plans

GoDaddy's web hosting gets a lot of things right. All shared plans include a 30-day money-back guarantee, a 99.9% uptime guarantee, automatic daily backups, unmetered bandwidth, new NVMe storage, a free domain for the first year, and cPanel (with email hosting).

Unfortunately, GoDaddy also gets a lot of things wrong. Expected security features like a web application firewall and malware scanning become paid add-ons after the first month, and if you're on the Economy plan, you'll be charged for an SSL certificate after the first year. DDoS protection is the only security feature that stays free on all plans.

Worth noting: GoDaddy's Managed WordPress plans resolve many of these shared hosting drawbacks by including full security and a CDN, though they introduce their own limitations, like one website per plan. We've included the entry-level Managed WordPress option below for comparison.

Support is provided 24/7 via chat, phone, and (for U.S. only) SMS.

• Web Hosting Economy: 1 website, 25 GB NVMe storage, 1 CPU, 512 MB RAM
• Managed WordPress Basic: 1 website, 10 GB NVMe storage, AIRO website builder
• Web Hosting Deluxe: 10 websites, 50 GB NVMe storage, 1 CPU, 1 GB RAM
• Web Hosting Ultimate: 25 websites, 75 GB NVMe storage, 2 CPU, 1.5 GB RAM

Which web host has the best security features?

HostGator blows GoDaddy away on security, and it’s not close.

	Our Pick
Malware scanning	Yes*	No**
Firewall protection		No**
DDoS protection
Backup frequency	Weekly	Daily
Other	2FA, Access Control	2FA, Access Control
Learn more	Get HostGator Read HostGator Review	Get GoDaddy Read GoDaddy Review

Malware scanning continuously monitors your site for malicious code and infected files, while firewall protection blocks suspicious traffic and attack patterns before they reach your website.

The fact that GoDaddy upsells these basic security features, when HostGator (and most other reputable hosts) include these for free, is a major downside of its shared web hosting. You're forced to choose between paying extra and being left vulnerable once the promotional period ends.

Considering that GoDaddy includes this same security on its managed WordPress plans, it comes across as a cash grab.

Which web host has the best support and reputation?

Despite GoDaddy's higher review scores and more support channel options, HostGator delivers a more straightforward support experience without the sales tactics and wait times that plague GoDaddy's chat support.

	Our Pick
24/7 customer support
Support options	Phone, live chat, email, knowledge base, online guides	Phone, live chat, AI chat, email, SMS (text), knowledge base
Trustpilot score	4.6	4.5
G2 rating	3.6	4.0
Capterra rating	3.8	4.2*
Learn more	Get HostGator Read HostGator Review	Get GoDaddy Read GoDaddy Review

Both providers offer 24/7 support through phone, live chat, email, and knowledge bases. GoDaddy adds AI chat and SMS support, but these extra channels come with frustrating drawbacks. The AI chatbot intentionally routes you to human agents after just two or three questions — even when it knows the answer — to create sales opportunities. This often means wait times pushing 30 minutes for simple questions that the bot could've answered instantly. Once connected, GoDaddy reps deflect straightforward questions to gather information for upsells, and they sometimes provide conflicting information that you'll need to fact-check or correct yourself.

HostGator isn't immune to the occasional misinformation either. Since parent company Newfold Digital uses the same support staff across multiple brands like HostGator and Bluehost, reps occasionally mix up which product features belong to which brand. However, HostGator's chat support focuses on actually answering your questions with minimal wait times and no sales theater, making these rare slip-ups far less frustrating than GoDaddy's attempts to convert almost every interaction into an upsell.

Customer reviews slightly favor GoDaddy across major platforms, with both companies receiving praise for responsive support teams. The common thread in negative feedback differs between the two: GoDaddy reviewers frequently cite aggressive upselling and confusing renewal pricing, while HostGator users occasionally report inconsistent service quality depending on which agent they reach.

Top alternatives

HostGator and GoDaddy are both popular hosting companies, but they are far from the only ones. If neither one resonates with you, then perhaps an alternative host might be a better choice. Three really good options are:

Bluehost: Think of Bluehost as HostGator’s cheaper, but paradoxically better cousin. It comes with all the features that HostGator does, but uses NVMe storage, adds an AI website builder on all plans, and includes ecommerce tools on its third-tier plan. Its plans are an overall better value than GoDaddy or HostGator.

Learn more in our Bluehost review.

Hostinger: If you compare Hostinger to GoDaddy or HostGator, you’ll find that Hostinger gives you most of the same features, but charges you less for them. Plus, you can pay for four years upfront, securing one of the longest promotional pricing periods in the industry.

Learn more in our Hostinger review.

IONOS: As another value leading host, IONOS, is famous for its $1/mo promotional pricing on select plans. It also offers fair renewal rates and includes the usual perks you’d expect from a good host — free SSL, free domain in the first year, unmetered bandwidth, email accounts, daily backups, and 24/7 support.

Learn more in our IONOS review.

HostGator vs. GoDaddy: Which is better?

HostGator sweeps GoDaddy across all categories.

	Our Pick
Value
Core features
Performance and reliability
Security
Support and reputation
Learn more	Get HostGator Read HostGator Review	Get GoDaddy Read GoDaddy Review

HostGator includes the essentials: malware scanning, firewall protection, staging environments, and a free CDN. GoDaddy either charges for these after the first month or, in the case of staging, doesn't offer it at all.

HostGator's support answers questions directly without lengthy waits or sales pitches, and you can host more sites per account with transparent traffic limits. GoDaddy's NVMe storage is faster, but for the average website, this advantage doesn't outweigh the additional costs and missing features.

Choose HostGator for better value, included features, and straightforward service. GoDaddy only makes sense if you need NVMe for database-heavy applications and don't mind paying for security.

FAQs